The neighbors were not surprised; Eiffler was an uneducated man, “with all the rudeness of a savage.” He had a reputation for cruelty, and even as a young boy had had invented modes of torturing animals. His wife had been devoted to him, but he treated her brutally and abused her in public. Eiffler had a mean, vengeful disposition and was hated and shunned by those who lived near him.
Stephen Effler was tried in the fall court term and found guilty of murder. He then filed an appeal with the state Supreme Court, claiming to be insane. While the matter was pending, Effler began acting strangely, and for months complained of a constant pain in his head. When the Supreme Court declared that Effler was sane, he admitted that he had been feigning insanity and vowed to live better in the little time he had left. In the spring term, the Superior Court sentenced him to hang on May 19, 1882.
The one person exempt from Stephen Effler’s cruelty was his little child. It was remarked that his love for the child was great, and he always treated it with kindness. Effler dictated his confession and had it printed up to be sold to the crowd at his execution to raise money for the orphan he would be leaving behind. He must have been successful in this venture, because, 8000 people came to witness the hanging.
Following prayers, Effler, standing on the gallows, delivered an hour-long harangue to the crowd. Although he had confessed to the murder, he contested the handling of the crime and accused the witnesses against him of perjury. Then he declared that he was ready to die. At 1:50 pm, the Deputy Sheriff cut the rope, and the trap fell. Six minutes later Stephen Effler was dead.
"Marion N. C." Indianapolis Sentinel 20 May 1882.
"Murder in McDowell." The Lenoir Topic 20 Jan 1881.
"Stephen Effler." National Police Gazette 22 Oct 1881.
"Stephen G. Effler Hanged." New York Herald 20 May 1882.