Seymour, Ind., Nov. 28. – An old murder mystery, resulting in four other tragedies, has just been cleared up. Moore Woodmansee, a wealthy merchant of Medora, nineteen miles from here, came to Seymour, January 3, 1866, on his way to Cincinnati. He had $2,000 with which to purchase goods. He was missed from his room at the Roder House, and the cause of his disappearance was a mystery until October, when his body was found in White River, with the head cut off. Gordon Kinney, an employee of the hotel, was suspected of the crime. When the excitement caused by the finding of the body was at its highest, an unknown man called Kinney from his door one night; as the latter opened the door he was shot and instantly killed.
In 1872 Reuben Wheeler was mortally wounded. When told he had to die, Wheeler made a confession, saying that on the night of Woodmansee’s murder two men had taken from the Roder stable the horse and spring-wagon. In the morning they returned. The bottom of the wagon was covered with blood. It was afterward taken out and new boards substituted. Roder was arrested for the murder, but acquitted; and again the affair was a dark mystery.
Every time during the many years that new evidence or news concerning the Woodmansee murder was reported, it was followed by a meeting of A. W. Flynn and “Sam” Long, gamblers and notorious characters. Suspicion began to point strongly toward them. Flynn threated to shoot one Emery who had talked about him but Emery shot first and instantly killed Flynn. “Sam” Long, the partner, disappeared; and Alden E. Rodman, a suspected accomplice, was one night taken by an unknown mob and hanged.
Within the last few days Eliza Kemp has arrived at Medora. She says that she occupied the room at the hotel adjoining Woodmansee’s the night of the murder. “I was suddenly awakened,” she says, “by a noise in room 7. In a second I was fully awake, and realized that someone in the next room was begging for life. I heard ‘Sam, kill the ------ ‘; then a blow, followed by a heavy fall, and a moan or two. Then someone said, ‘He is dead, --- him.’ They then agreed to take his body, cut his head off and throw the trunk in the river. I left Seymour early in the morning, and have never told what I heard. I am going to Kansas in a few days, or would not now tell what I do; because my life has been threatened time and time again by anonymous letters and in other ways.”
Five of the six supposed to have been connected with this murder have been killed; and “Sam” Long, the only one remaining, left in 1866, and has never been seen or heard of.
"An Ancient Mystery Solved.." New York Tribune 29 Nov 1883.