Saturday, October 31, 2026

Caught in the Act.

(The National Police Gazette, October 2, 1886.)
A little before 3 o’clock, on the afternoon of September 9, 1886, Henry H. Meyer rushed into the police station in Memphis, Tennessee, and said, “I have just killed a man, and I want to give myself up.”

Captain Hackett took down the information and had the man locked up, then hurried to the address he had given to see for himself what had happened. In an upstairs room, he found William B. Dunnavant lying on the floor, very nearly dead, bleeding from a gunshot wound to the chest. “I am to blame,” Dunnavant moaned. He died soon after.

Dunnavant was taking liberties with Meyer’s wife, but he didn’t know that Meyer was watching from a wardrobe. Meyer jumped out, brandishing a pistol, and  Dunnavant was shot in the scuffle.


Read the full story here: In Flagrante Delicto.

Saturday, October 24, 2026

The Three Hangings, Lycoming County.

This week, we feature a guest post by Don Everett Smith Jr., author of The Goffle Road Murders of Passaic County (History Press, 2011).   In a previous post on Murder by Gaslight, “Revisiting the Goffle Road Murders,” Don presented an excerpt from his book. This week’s post, “The Three Hangings, Lycoming County,” examines the 1880 murder of Andrew Miller in Lycoming County, Pennsylvania, and the prosecution of his killers.


The Three Hangings, Lycoming County.

Murder 

Lycoming County, Pennsylvania; 1880 – 1881

It was near springtime in 1880 when a small Lycoming County town, of Pine Creek, was shocked by the brutal death of a beloved Civil War veteran named Andrew Miller.  According to Feb. 4th, 1881 The Daily Banner, Miller was described as being 58 years old in 1880 and married to a woman 20 years younger named Catherine Rush. They had three girls and he supported them as “a laborer by occupation, working for a livelihood at such work as he could get in a farming community.”  

Miller was described as a “plain unassuming man, poor and industrious.”  He was “faithful and good to his wife’s parents” and a “hard and ready worker, kind and obliging to everybody.” However, on March 19th, 1880, in the early morning, “Andrew Miller had committed suicide by hanging himself” in the barn on his rented homestead. 

Saturday, October 17, 2026

Carlyle and Helen.

 

Carlyle Harris and Helen Potts.
(The Trial of Carlyle W. Harris for Poisoning His Wife, Helen Potts, at New York.)

Helen Potts, a nineteen-year-old student at Miss Comstock’s School in New York City, decided not to join her roommates when they went to hear a concert. Helen was feeling ill, but her boyfriend (secretly her husband), a medical student named Carlyle Harris, had prescribed a remedy. When the girls returned, Helen told them of the wonderful dreams she had been having about Carlyle. But she also complained of numbness throughout her body; before long, she could not move, and her breathing was labored. The dreams soon vanished, giving way to nightmares, revealing a world filled with deceit, betrayal, and ultimately murder.

Read the full story here: The Six Capsules.





Saturday, October 10, 2026

Laura and Alexander.

 

Laura D. Fair and Alexander P. Crittenden

A prominent California legislator was sitting with his wife and son on board the Oakland-San Francisco ferryboat El Capitain the evening of November 3, 1870. They did not notice the woman approaching them, dressed entirely in black, wearing a broad-brimmed black hat with a black veil covering her face. From the folds of her dress, the woman pulled a derringer and shot the man in the chest. The family recognized the woman in black then; it was Laura Fair, and she was finally ending her tumultuous affair with Alexander P. Crittenden.

Read the full story here: The Woman in Black.

Saturday, October 3, 2026

A Cursed Murderer in Lowell, Mass.

William H. Devlin
(Illustrated Police News, December 22, 1877)

Shortly after noon on Monday, December 10, 1877, a man entered the Lowell, Massachusetts, Police Station in a highly excited state. He told Deputy Marshal Favor that he had heard a terrible fight between a husband and wife Saturday night in a tenement on Common Street. Since then, he had heard nothing from the house, and he feared the wife might be injured. Favor paid little attention; such reports were not unusual, but he sent officers Harris and McCaffrey to investigate.

The officers went to the home of William and Ellen Devlin and found the door locked. After receiving no response to their knocks, they broke it open. Inside, they were shocked to find a woman lying on the bedroom floor, battered and wounded, blood oozing from a deep gash behind her left ear, and her whole face was swollen and distorted, all indicating an agonizing death. On her breast, an infant lay dead, its neck and face showing signs of brutal treatment.