|Fanny Windley Hyde|
Victim: George W. Watson
Cause of Death: Shooting
Accused: Fanny Windley Hyde
John Windley brought his family to America from Nottingham, England in 1864. He was a poor man and Fanny Windley had begun working in England when she was eight years old. She was ten when they arrived in America and soon after began the life of a factory girl in Brooklyn. She was a bright girl, attending school when she could evenings and Sunday, and as she approached adolescence she was also considered quite beautiful.
|George W. Watson|
Inevitably, Fanny became pregnant and Watson gave her some medicine to induce abortion. The medicine did the job, but had the additional effect of destroying Fanny’s health. During this period Fanny had moved out of her father’s house. She came to see him after two months absence and both her father and stepmother commented on how much weight she had lost and how pale she was. Her weight had dropped from 125 pounds to 95 pounds.
At her new lodgings Fanny met a man named Hyde, a widower with a daughter around her own age. He asked her to marry him and she agreed. George Watson had promised Fanny that if she married he would leave her alone—in fact she had him swear to this on a Bible. But the promise did not last long, and soon Watson was up to his old tricks. This time Fanny told her husband, and Hyde was livid. He went to see Watson himself, and threatened to expose the situation to Watson’s wife. Once again Watson promised to leave Fanny alone, and once again he broke his promise.
In January 1872, Fanny’s brother helped her buy a gun—she said she intended to use it only to frighten Watson away from her. The pistol was small enough to conceal in the bosom of her dress and it was hidden there when she went into the factory on January 23. She met Watson on a landing of the stairway as he was leaving the office for lunch. There she shot Watson in the head, killing him. Several hours later Fanny turned herself in to the police.
Trial: April 15, 1872
The prosecution of Fanny Hyde was one of the sensational New York murder trials that dominated headlines in the 1800s. Watson’s family hired a prominent criminal attorney to assist the prosecution, making sure that Fanny was convicted and as much as possible mitigating the damage to George Watson’s reputation. The district attorney declined the offer. He believed it was an open-and-shut case of premeditated murder—Fannie had laid in wait on the stairway landing and shot Watson in cold blood.
The defense argued that it had not been coldblooded murder; it was a chance meeting on the stairway, Watson accosted her as usual and Fanny had resisted. There was evidence that she had fought him off—the body was found with scratch marks on the face. When this did not stop him, Fanny pulled the pistol from her bosom and shot. In her own testimony, Fanny recalled that Watson had called her a whore and said she should go with him. She had no recollection of the shot itself.
The defense took a two pronged attack. First they argued for justifiable homicide:
"Why, gentlemen, the meanest worm that walks the earth in human form, the frailest thing that revels night and day in the meanest dens of infamy, is mistress of her own body; and the man who dares to lay violent hands on that body against her will, and attempts to use it against her will, and she kills him, she is justified in doing so, and so the Court will instruct you."Then they argued for temporary insanity:
"We shall demonstrate to you, as clear as sunlight, that the defendant was no more responsible at the time of firing that shot than the pistol from which it was fired. Her mind was stormed in its citadel, and laid prostrate under a stroke of frenzy."In either case:
"Don’t you see enough in this case to show you what a weight of grief must have borne down upon this frail creature’s head and heart; that this act was perpetrated under a weight of grief that could not be resisted."The case was given to the jury at 2:30 pm on April 19. They seemed somewhat baffled over what direction to take and at 10:30 they requested that the court provide them with precise definitions of first degree murder, manslaughter in the third degree, and justifiable homicide. The judge declared that they had already been given those definitions, but obliged them anyway. At around midnight they sent word that they were hopelessly deadlocked. The judge sent them back and told them to work out an agreement. At 7:00 the next morning they tearfully told the judge there was no possibility of agreement.
The New York Times reported that the jury had been swayed by sentiment toward a pretty woman. Ten jurors had voted for acquittal while the other two wanted third degree manslaughter. A compromised was proposed in which they would find Mrs. Hyde guilty of fourth degree manslaughter. The resulting fine of $1,000 would be paid by the ten jurors favoring acquittal. It was not enough to sway the holdouts and the jury remained deadlocked.
Verdict: Hung jury
Fanny Hyde was released on $2,500 bail. In January 1873 her case was called again and Fanny failed to appear, forfeiting her bail. In March she was arrested and sent to Brooklyn’s Raymond Street jail to await trial. There she met Kate Stoddard, the city’s latest sensational defendant. In September 1873 Fanny Hyde was again released on $2,500 bail. She was never heard from again.