Date: May 11, 1833
Location: Morristown, New Jersey
Victim: Samuel and Sarah Sayre, and their servant Phoebe
Cause of Death: Clubbing
Accused: Antoine Le Blanc
Antoine Le Blanc came to America from the Moselle region of France leaving behind his sweetheart, a woman named Marie. They were in love but Marie’s parents rejected Le Blanc as too poor and low-bred. Le Blanc’s plan was to attain wealth in the New World and return to France a more acceptable suitor for Marie.
Within a few days of his arrival on April 26, 1833, Le Blanc was fortunate enough to find work at the farm of Samuel and Sarah Sayre. The Sayres were a prominent and well to do couple in their sixties, living with an African American servant named Phoebe, who may have been a slave. The Sayres needed help with the farm work; they had owned a young slave boy who ran off leaving them with no one to help with the spring planting.
The relationship was tense from the start; Le Blanc spoke no English and the Sayres spoke no French. In addition to communication problems, other workers on the farm complained of Le Blanc’s cigar smoking and poor personal hygiene. For Le Blanc, resentment grew when the job he thought would be simple gardening turned out to be strenuous farm work and the he would be working for room and board only.
The night of May 11, 1833, after drinking hard cider at a local tavern, Le Blanc returned to the farmhouse. He found Samuel Sayre upstairs shaving. Gesturing excitedly, Le Blanc motioned for Sayre to follow him to the stable. There he killed Sayre with a single blow the back of the head with a spade. He lured Sarah Sayre to the stable the same way. He knocked her down with the spade but she did not die right away. He hit her again with the spade, then as she pleaded for her life, Le Blanc kicked her to death with his boot.
Le Blanc buried the bodies under a pile of manure and went back into the farmhouse. He sneaked into Phoebe’s bedroom and murdered her in her sleep. Accounts differ on how he killed Phoebe; he may have clubbed her, split her skull with an axe, or rammed a pitchfork into her chest.
He then ransacked the place, prying open ever box and drawer in the house and loading everything of value—coins and silverware down to thimbles and toothbrushes— into pillowcases. He changed his bloody clothing for one of Samuel Sayre’s suites, stole a horse and fled.
The plan was to pawn the valuables in New York and board a ship to Germany before the bodies were discovered. However, in his haste, Le Blanc had not secured the pillowcases and stolen items began to fall out as he rode. The next morning a piece of the Sayre’s monogramed silver was found on the road. The bodies were discovered and Sheriff George Ludlow led a posse who followed the trail of booty to the Mosquito Tavern in the Hackensack Meadows. Le Blanc was arrested and taken back to Morristown.