Jack the Strangler.

New York Journal, March 18, 1898.

When the news of London’s 1888 Whitechapel Murders, attributed to “Jack the Ripper,” crossed the Atlantic, Americans were instantly fascinated. The vision of a dark, elusive killer, mutilating women without motive, was morbidly titillating, and the name Jack the Ripper fired the popular imagination. In the nascent age of yellow journalism, no one was more fascinated by Jack the Ripper than newspaper reporters who began seeing Ripper-like murders everywhere they looked.

Sensational murder reporting had been a staple of American newspapers since the 1830s, and multiple murderers (serial killers) were active in America throughout the 19^th-century. But the fear of deranged killers roaming the streets and killing at random was something new. Journalists instinctively saw the value of linking unsolved murders to a single individual and comparing him to Jack the Ripper. They invariably attributed groups of unsolved murders to some local version of Jack. 

The Humboldt Herald commented on this trend in 1889:

 

Since Jack the Ripper emerged into public notice at Whitechapel, London, this country has sprung upon it Jack the Choker, Jack the Kisser, Jack the Strangler, and Jack the Window-breaker. Now, if Jack the Hanger, would come along and hang the whole outfit, himself included, a long-suffering public would clap its hands and cry “Bravo!” 

The name that caught on in America was Jack the Strangler, as a rash of unsolved strangulation cases spread throughout the country. In 1894, three strangulation deaths in Denver, Colorado, were attributed to Jack the Strangler; San Francisco’s Jack the Strangler also murdered three. Jack the Strangler murders were reported in cities throughout America, including Sebolia, Arizona, Nebraska City, Nebraska, Evansville, Indiana, Uniontown, Pennsylvania, and Skagway, Alaska.

 

When Denver reported a fourth strangulation in 1898, the New York Journal postulated that ten women in cities across the country had been murdered by the same Jack the Strangler. The first was Minnie Weldt, strangled in New York City in November 1894. The Strangler then went to Buffalo, New York, and murdered Josie Bennet that June. From there, to Cincinnati, where he strangled Mary Eckhart in July. In September, he arrived in Denver, and over the next three months, strangled Lena Tupper, Mary Contassolt, and Kiku Oyama. He took a year off, then surfaced in San Francisco, and between December 1895 and March 1896, he murdered Jessie Williams, Marie McDermott, and Bertha Paradis. After another hiatus, he returned to Denver and killed Julia Voght in October 1898.

 

This scenario is highly unlikely, but the first name on the list, Minnie Weldt, was linked to a series of New York City murders that would later be attributed to New York’s own Jack the Strangler. The New York press seldom used the name Jack the Strangler, but as the cases began to pile up, with similar circumstances and locations, it was hard to ignore the possibility of a single killer. The papers came up with many Strangler theories, but were never able to identify him.

 

Between 1894 and 1900, eight women living in New York’s Tenderloin district centered around 2^nd Avenue were strangled in their homes. Most were already known to the police as women of low moral character. Not one of these cases was ever solved:

 

New York Journal, August 24, 1900.

May 6, 1894 – Minnie Weldt, a 22-year-old washerwoman, with many male visitors, was found strangled with a handkerchief in her home at 224 E. 61^st Street.

 

May 31, 1896 – Mamie Cuningham, a girl of 13, was beaten and strangled with a towel in her home at 315 E. 67^th Street.

 

August 3, 1896 – Annie Bock, a 23-year-old “social outcast,” was beaten, strangled, and slashed in her home at 207 E 23^rd Street.

 

September 2, 1896 – Hannah Altman, aka “Dutch Annie,” a friend of Annie Bock, was strangled with a stocking in her home at 202 E. 29^th Street.

 

November 9, 1896 – Pauline Bennett, 24, was robbed and strangled in the rooms she was using for “immoral purposes” at 11 St. Marks Place

 

April 22, 1897 – “Diamond Flossie” Murphy, an opium addict, was strangled with a rope and robbed of $1,500 in jewelry

 

March 15, 1898 – Maggie Crowley, a 35-year-old woman with a drinking problem, was strangled and dragged to the courtyard outside her home at 27 Monroe Street

 

August 20, 1900 – Katy Scharn, a 24-year-old factory worker, who frequented a “cheap concert hall,” was strangled and beaten with a hammer at her home at 674 2^nd Avenue.

 

 

In coming weeks, Murder by Gaslight will take a closer look at these cases and try to determine if they all could have been victims of one single Jack the Strangler.

---

Sources:

“"Jack the Strangler",” The Akron Beacon Journal, October 29, 1894.
“Another Victim,” The Akron Beacon Journal, November 13, 1894.
“Darkness Sheds Light on Death,” New York journal and advertiser., April 24, 1897.
“Did He Strangle in Other Cities?,” New York journal and advertiser., May 15, 1897.
“Evidence That One "Jack the Strangler" Killed Kate Scharn and at Least 2 Others.,” New York Journal and Advertiser, August 23, 1900.
“Four Deaths Traceable to Hand of Strangler,” EVANSVILLE COURIER., November 15, 1901.
'Frisco Has a Jack the Strangler,” WATERTOWN DAILY TIMES., March 10, 1896.
“Has Denver a "Jack the Strangler"?,” The New York Times, November 14, 1894.
“His Mark,” The Cincinnati Enquirer, February 19, 1892.
Humboldt Herald, March 15, 1889.
“Is Still a Mystery,” Sun-Journal, August 24, 1900.
“Jack the Strangler,” The Lincoln Daily Sun, July 13, 1892.
“Jack the Strangler,” The Cleveland Leader, October 30, 1894.
“Jack the Strangler,” Green Bay Press-Gazette, November 13, 1894.
“Jack the Strangler,” New York Herald, March 28, 1896.
“Jack the Strangler Seizes Young Girls,” DETROIT TO DAY, November 25, 1902.
“Lincoln Price,” New York Journal and Advertiser, August 24, 1900.
“May be the Strangler Who Has Cruelly Murdered So Many Hapless Women,” New York Journal, March 16, 1898.
“Murderer of Four Women,” Akron daily Democrat., November 14, 1901.
“New Clews,” New York Journal and Advertiser, August 23, 1900.
“New York's Women Murder Mysteries of the Past,” New York Journal and Advertiser, August 20, 1900.
“Police Mystified by Murders,” EVANSVILLE JOURNAL-NEWS, November 15, 1901.
“Slain by Jack the Strangler,” The San Francisco Examiner, November 14, 1894.
“Strangler Gets Another Victim.,” New York Journal and Advertiser, October 9, 1898.
“Strangler Mark on Dead Woman's Neck,” New York evening journal., March 15, 1898.
“Stranglers of Women,” New York Herald, June 7, 1896.
“Strangler's Sign on a Child's Body,” New York journal and advertiser., June 17, 1897.
“The Denver Mystery,” The San Francisco Examiner, November 19, 1894.
“Victims of a Mysterious Strangler,” New York Journal, March 18, 1898.

Butchered and Burned.

National Police Gazette, January 28, 1882

Mrs. J.W. Gibbons was away from her home in Ashland, Kentucky, on December 23, 1881. She left behind her 18-year-old son Robert, her 14-year-old daughter Fannie, and 17-year-old Emma Thomas (aka Carico), who was staying with them. Mrs. Gibbons returned the following day to find her home burned to the ground and all three inhabitants dead.

Read the full story here: The Ashland Outrage.

Maggie Crowley, Found Strangled.

Maggie Crowley
(New York American, March 16, 1898)

Robert Hoey, coming home from work in the early hours of March 15, 1898, literally tripped over the body of a dead woman in the courtyard of his New York City tenement. The woman had been strangled to death and dragged to the courtyard known in the neighborhood as “Hogan’s Alley.” Four days later, she was identified as Maggie Crowley, a young woman with a drinking problem. Four men were suspected, two were indicted, but no one was convicted.

Read the full story here: Murder Told in Pictures.

Frederick F. Streeter.

About half past three, the morning of July 2, 1863, a young man on his way to work in Medina, Ohio, saw the home of Shubal Coy in flames. He alerted the neighbors, who came out to douse the flames with water. When the fire was under control, they went inside to look for the Coy family. They found Shubal lying in bed with nine stab wounds in his throat and breast, any one of them capable of producing death. His wife lay on the floor, with her throat cut. She had fought with her attacker and had twenty-four cuts on her head and body. Their seven-year-old son Ferdinand lay in bed with his throat cut. Mercifully, it appeared he was murdered in his sleep.

Medford's Murder Mystery.

(Boston Post, March 29, 1897,)

Walter R. Debbins was shot twice in the back, in broad daylight, on Highland Street in Medford, Massachusetts, on the afternoon of Saturday, March 27, 1897. Though no one saw the murder or heard the gunshots, there was enough traffic on Highland Street that afternoon for the police to precisely pinpoint the time of the shooting to between 1:00 and 1:05. But that was all they could pinpoint; everything else about the crime was shrouded in mystery that grew more dense with each new revelation.

 

Read the full story here: The Medford Mystery.

Sororcide.

The Murder of Lizzie Anderson

Josie Fay was standing at the corner of Bowker and Sudbury Streets in Boston’s West End, on the evening of January 19, 1880. Stella Vannell approached her and asked if she had seen Ida King. Josie pointed down Bowker Street, where Ida stood talking with a young man named Michael Tolan. Stella walked up to the couple, called out to Ida, and began making disparaging remarks about Tolan. The women exchanged angry words, and the argument escalated until, in a flash, Stella drew a large clasp-knife and plunged it into Ida’s breast. Both women were drunk at the time of the incident, and both were using assumed names. In fact, they were sisters, Maggie and Lizzie Anderson.

Harry and Catherine.

 

Harry and Catherine.
(Harry Hayward: Life, crimes, dying confession and execution of the Celebrated Minneapolis Criminal.)

Harry Hayward was a handsome young conman from a wealthy Minneapolis family. He persuaded Catherine Ging to make him beneficiary on a life insurance policy, then, on December 3, 1894, he lured her to her death. 

Read the full story here: The Minneapolis Svengali.

A Murder on Ice.

A group of young boys from Lambertville, New Jersey, went skating on Island Creek on December 15, 1880. They brought their lunches and, when they sat down to eat, they built a fire on the ice to keep warm. John Pierman, an older boy (age reported variously as 15, 16, or 18) with another group, came upon them and started kicking the burning wood around the ice. Theodore Parker, aged 13 or 14, told Pierman to stop. An argument ensued and words led to blows. When Parker struck Pierman in the face, breaking his pipe, Pierman pulled out a knife and plunged it into Parker’s left breast, piercing his heart.

Clara and Daniel.

 

("On Trial for Murder," Daily Inter Ocean, November 27, 1895.)

During a time of conflict between the Shanks family and the Keller family in rural Indiana, the body of 18-year-old Clara Shanks was found floating in Wolf Creek. Circumstantial evidence pointed to Daniel Keller, who had a clandestine romance with Clara.

Read the full story here: The Wolf Creek Tragedy.

So far From Home: The Pearl Bryan Murder.

 So far From Home: The Pearl Bryan Murder - Amazon, Audible.

Who Killed Carrie Farrel?

Mrs. Carrie Farrel left her home in Sibley, Iowa, at 7:00 a.m. on May 6, 1889. She went on horseback to visit her parents, who lived about two miles away. When she didn’t return that night, her husband thought nothing strange of her absence. It was not unusual for Carrie to spend the night with her parents. But when her horse returned home riderless the following morning, her husband became alarmed and began searching for her.

James and Sarah Jane.

 

James E. Eldredge and Sarah Jane Gould.
(The Trial of James E Eldredge )

James E. Eldredge left his home in Canton, New York in the spring of 1856. He returned six months later with a new name and a duplicitous personality to match. All those around him soon learned to distrust anything the young man said—all except his fiancé, Sarah Jane Gould. She remained trusting to the end, when Eldredge poisoned Sarah Jane to pursue her younger sister.

Read the full story here: James E. Eldredge.

Asked His Wife to Shoot Him.

Lourens Signourette and his wife lived near Foster’s Bar, a remote camp in the Yubas Foot Hills in California. Lourens had been ailing for quite a while, and on December 1, 1891, he decided to end his life by taking strychnine. The poison did not have the immediate effect that he wanted, so he asked his wife to get his shotgun and shoot him.

The Late Mr. Benjamin Nathan.

Harper's Weekly, August 20, 1870.

Benjamin Nathan, a wealthy stockbroker and philanthropist, was found brutally beaten to death in his Manhattan home the morning of July 29, 1870. Some jewelry and a small amount of cash were stolen, and the police were quick to rule the incident a burglary gone bad. But if so, how and when did the burglars enter? And how could four others staying in the house sleep through the violent attack? In fact, the Nathan murder looked more like a classic locked-room mystery—a mystery that remains unsolved.

Read the full story here:

Who Killed Benjamin Nathan?

The Crosby Street Murder.

At around 6:30, the morning of February 4, 1877, the residents of Crosby Street in New York City were alarmed by a woman’s shriek. Many were preparing for church that Sunday morning, and from their windows, they watched the woman, barefoot, wearing just a skirt and a thin chemise, run across the street, pursued by a man wielding what appeared to be a long iron spike. She ran to the house at 52 Crosby Street, screaming, “Open the door; for the blessed Virgin’s sake, open the door.”

Frank and Christie.

Frank Almy and Christie Warden.
(Life, Trial, and Confession of Frank C. Almy, Laconia, N.H.: J.J. Lane, 1891.)

While working as a farmhand in Hanover, New Hampshire, career criminal Frank Almy (aka George Abbott) fell in love with the farmer’s daughter, Christie Warden. When Christie did not return his love Abbot went back to his old ways and took it at gunpoint in the shady hollow known as the Vale of Tempe.

Read the full story here: Murder in the Vale of Tempe.

Murderous Christmas Celebrations.

Murder never pauses for Christmas; it is all too often an unwelcome guest at Yuletide parties.

Here are a few murderous nineteenth-century American Christmas "celebrations." 

	Two Shots, a Shriek. “A dark, mean little bedroom, a woman, half-undressed, dirty and pale, and blear-eyed from long excesses, a male companion, leaning over her with a revolver at her head, two shots, a shriek, an ugly hole under the ear, and the vice and crime of Boston had added another murder to its long score.”  - The Boston Herald’s vivid description of the murder of Josephine Brown on Christmas Eve, 1891.
	It was Santa Claus' Fault. On Christmas Eve, 1889, chaos ensued at a  Shawneetown, Illinois, Christmas party, when the tags fell off some of the presents and were replaced haphazardly.  The room erupted into a free fight with chairs, clubs, knives, and pistols. it looked as though several combatants would be killed, but none of the wounds proved fatal. A Christmas miracle.
	Mrs. Southern's Sad Case. At a Pickens County, Georgia Christmas party in 1876, Kate Southern warned her husband not to dance with his mistress, Narcissa Cowan, and she warned Narcissa to stay away from her husband. When they danced together anyway Kate borrowed her father's pocketknife and plunged it into Narcissa's chest.
	That Bad Man Stagolee. Troubadours have sung the story of Stagolee for over a hundred years. Each singer seems to know a different version and tell a different story of its origin. But the story is true. The legend was born when Stack Lee Shelton shot Billy Lyons, in a fight over a Stetson hat, in Bill Curtis's Saloon, on Christmas night 1895.
	Delia's Gone, One More Round. On Christmas Eve 1900, Cooney Houston shot and killed Delia Green. If that isn’t tragic enough, they were both 14 years old. Their sad story would have been long forgotten, even in Yamacraw – the black neighborhood in the western end of Savannah, Georgia, where the killing took place – if it hadn’t been for a song. The ballad of Delia’s murder traveled from Georgia to the Bahamas, then back to the States during the folk boom of the 1950s.

The Just End of a Monster of Iniquity.

 

Dr. Thomas Neill Cream, “The Lambeth Poisoner” and possible Jack the Ripper suspect, was hanged at Newgate Prison in London on November 15, 1892. Dr. Cream had already been convicted of murder by strychnine in the United States. In fact, if he had not been released early from Chicago’s Joliet Prison, four young London women would have been spared excruciating death. 

Read the full story here:  The Lambeth Poisoner.

The Knife in Boston.

On the afternoon of November 27, 1874, Aaron P Barnes went, with his business assistant, John W. Ganie, to a lodging house Barnes owned on Gouch Street in Boston. One of the lodgers had left, and they wanted to ensure the room was ready for the next tenant. They went upstairs and found three young ruffians, somewhat intoxicated, lounging in the furnished but otherwise vacated room.

The men, Richard Nealon, James McCall, and George Watson (alias Jeremiah Cummings), appeared ready for a permanent stay. Barnes told them to leave, and they refused. An argument ensued.

McCall stepped up and said, “Shut your mouth; I’ll shoot you.”

Adolph and Lizzie.

(National Police Gazette, November 20, 1881.)

After less than two years of marriage in Iowa City, Iowa, Lizzie Stein filed for divorce from her husband, Adolph. She was tired of Adolph’s abuse, but he said that he would not live without Lizzie. When the divorce became final, on November 4, 1881, Adolph slashed and stabbed Lizzie, then he poisoned himself with belladonna.

 “The horror of the deed threw a chill over the entire city, and the remembrance of it will not pass away for many years,” said the Chicago Tribune.

Read the full story here: A Day of Blood.