Saturday, November 21, 2026

Tragedy Caused by a Cruel Joke.

(Philadelphia Inquirer, August 25, 1897.)

 

On August 23, 1897, William Rooney, a 25-year-old bicycle store manager, sent a message to his 19-year-old paramour, Verona Sellhelm:

 

Philadelphia, Aug. 23, 1897

Dear Verona: Please let me know if I can see you this evening; if so, where.

Yours truly,  W.R.

 

The response he received was:

 

Will see you tonight at 8 o’clock at Eighth and Girard Avenue.

Verona.

 

Rooney was pleased with the response and that evening stopped for a few drinks before heading to Eighth and Girard. He arrived by streetcar at the appointed time, but when he stepped off the car he saw Verona walking away with Alphonse Picard, another of her suitors. Incensed, Rooney went after them.

 

Verona turned and saw Rooney following them. “I am with you,” said Picard, “so you need not be scared. Don’t mind him.”

 

Looking again, Verona saw Rooney pull a pistol from his pocket. She was about to run when two shots rang out, and Picard fell to the ground. Rooney kept firing, hitting Verona as she ran. Rooney fled the scene and, though wounded, Verona went back to where Picard had fallen. “She frantically tore open his shirt,” said the Philadelphia Inquirer, “and on seeing two bullet wounds over his heart, pressed a kiss upon his lips and then swooned.” Verona was taken to the hospital where surgeons worked on removing the bullets.

 

Policeman Tyson, aided by a private citizen, captured and disarmed Rooney. At the police station, Rooney’s excuse was that he “did not propose to be made a guy of by a woman.”

 

In the 1890s, the word “guy” meant something different than it does today. The American Slang Dictionary, published in 1891, defined it this way:

 

Guy: “a fright; an ill-dressed person.”

Guy: “to make fun of; to roast or ‘josh’ a person.”

 

Rooney meant the second sense of “guy.” He thought Verona had deliberately taunted him. In fact, the incident had been the result of a cruel joke, but not in the way Rooney thought. When Verona received Rooney’s note, she said to the messenger, “Tell him, no.” She did not send a written reply. Alphonse Picard’s younger brother Harry saw the note and thought it would be fun to disappoint Rooney and keep him waiting on the corner. He wrote the reply on a card and told the messenger to deliver it to Rooney.

 

A great crowd gathered around the police station, hoping to get a glimpse of the prisoner, but Rooney was taken to Moyamensing Prison where he would remain until his trial.

 

Another crowd gathered at the home of Alphonse Picard’s mother, where his memorial service was held. Several policemen were needed to keep people from jamming the entrance. Only those known to the family were allowed in. Among the many floral tributes was a cluster of 25 roses from Verona Sellhelm. But no one grieved more than Harry Picard.


 “Even the grief of the mother,” said the Inquirer, “was not so great as that of Harry Picard, the younger brother, whose thoughtless joke drew Rooney to the place where, finding Verona and Alphonse together, he shot them.”

 

The trial of William Rooney began on November 29, 1897. The prosecution said the crime was premeditated. They asked for a verdict of first-degree murder and the death penalty. Carrie A. Wagner, a friend of both Verona and Rooney, testified that Rooney had called on her in May 1897, worried that he was losing Verona. After professing great love for her, he concluded by saying, “So help me God, I’ll kill her.” Wagner added that Rooney was drunk at the time and did not know what he was speaking about.


Because of Harry Picard’s cruel joke, public sentiment had turned in Rooney’s favor.  After deliberating for seventeen hours, the jury returned a verdict of “Guilty of murder in the second degree.” Rooney was sentenced to twenty years in prison, but he escaped the gallows.


Sources: 
James Maitland, The American Slang Dictionary (Chicago: James Maitland, 1891.) 
“Alphonse L Picard is Laid at Rest,” Philadelphia Inquirer, August 27, 1897.
“Excuse for Double Murder,” Indianapolis journal., August 24, 1897.
“How Picard Died,” Philadelphia Inquirer, September 4, 1897.
“Jealousy Causes Murder,” San Francisco call., August 24, 1897.
“Rooney Arraigned for Picard's Murder,” The Philadelphia Inquirer, November 30, 1897.
“Rooney Sentenced to Twenty Years,” The Philadelphia Inquirer, December 2, 1897.
“Tragedy Caused by a Cruel Joke,” Philadelphia Inquirer, August 25, 1897.
“Unnecessary Sympathy,” Scranton tribune., August 27, 1897.
“William Rooney Formally Indicted,” The Philadelphia Inquirer, September 15, 1897.


 


 


No comments:

Post a Comment